CASES DECIDED

IN THE

SUPREME COURT

OF

MICHIGAN

FROM

OCTOBER 1 TO NOVEMBER 8, 1912

JAMES M. REASONER

STATE REPORTER

VOL. 172

FIRST EDITION

CHICAGO

CALLAGHAN AND COMPANY

1913

Copyright, 1913. by Frederick C. Martindale, Secretary of State,

CLERK-CHARLES C. HOPKINS, LANSING.
CRIER-ANDREW B. CHAPIN, LANSING.

ATTORNEY GENERAL-ROGER I. WYKES, GRAND RAPIDS.

Pursuant to Act No. 182, Public Acts 1893, the Justices reside at Lansing during their terms of office.

SUPERIOR COURT of Grand RAPIDS, WILLIAM J. STUART.