PRINTED IN GREAT BRITAIN BY RICHARD CLAY & Sons, LIMITED,

BUNGAY, SUFFOLK.

correspondents:

Prof. C. R. Fay for CANADA

Prof. CHARLES Gide for FRANCE (University of Toronto).

(University of Paris) Prof. H. STANLEY JEvons for INDIA

Prof. A. ANDRÉADÈS , GREECE (University of Allahabad).

(University of Athons). Mr. A. DUCKWORTH for New South WALES Prof. G. W. J. Bruins for HOLLAND (Australian Mutual Provident Society, Sydney).

(Rotterdam School of Commerce). Prof. JAMES Hight for NEW ZEALAND Prof. A. Loria for ITALY (Canterbury College).

(University of Turin). Prof. R. A. LEHFELDT for SOUTH AFRICA Mr. JiuchI SOYEDA for JAPAN (School of Mines and Technology, Johannesburg).

(Industrial Bank of Japan, Tokyo). Prof. SCHUMPETER for AUSTRIA

Prof. F. BERNIS for SPAIN (University of Vienna).

(University of Salamanca). Prof. E. MAHAIM „ BELGIUM

Prof. G. CASSELL » SWEDEN (University of Liége).

(University of Stockholm). Prof. H. WESTERGAARD for DENMARK

Prof. E. R. A. SELIGMAN for UNITED STATES (University of Copenhagen). |

(Columbia University, New York).

THE ROYAL ECONOMIC SOCIETY (incorporated by Royal Charter, 1902) was founded, under the name of the BRITISH ECONOMIC ASSOCIATION, at a meeting held at University College, London, on November 20th, 1890, the Right Hon. G. J. Goschen, M.P. (the late Viscount Goschen), in the Chair.

The Society has for its object the general advancement of economic knowledge.

The Journal of the Society, published quarterly by Messrs. Macmillan and Co., Ltd., London, and sent post free to Fellows, is intended to represent the various shades of economic opinion, and to be the organ, not of one school of economists, but of all. The Journal numbers among its contributors the leading economists of all countries. Fellows are entitled in addition to the Journal, to copies of sundry other publications issued by the Society from time to time.

Apart from the Annual Meeting a Congress of the Society has been periodically convened for the discussion of social and economic questions and opportunity has thus been afforded for the reunion of Fellows.

By arrangement with the London School of Economics, Fellows of the Royal Economic Society may obtain from the Secretary a card entitling them to the use of the valuable library of that institution.

Patron-HIS MAJESTY THE KING.

Council:
The Right Hon. VISCOUNT HALDANE of CLOAN, O.M., F.R.S., President.
The Right Hon. THE EARL OF BALFOUR, K.G.,)
O.M., F.R.S.

Į Vice-Presidents.
PROFESSOR F. Y. EDGEWORTH, F.B.A.

The Right Hon. VISCOUNT MILNER, G.C.B.
Sir WILLIAM M. ACWORTH, K.C.S.I.

Dr. T. E. GREGORY. Sir CHARLES ADDIS, K.C.M.G.

Mr. R. G. HAWTREY. Professor Sir WILLIAM ASHLEY.

Mr. HENRY Higgs, C.B. Professor C. F. BASTABLE, F.B.A.

Professor LILIAN KNOWLES. Sir WILLIAM BEVERIDGE, K.C.B.

Mr. W. T. Layton, C.H., C.B.E. Dr. JAMES BONAR.

Professor D. H. MACGREGOR. Professor A. L. BOWLEY, So.D., F.B. A.

Professor H. O. MEREDITH. The Hon. R. H. BRAND.

Professor J. S. NICHOLSON, F.B.A. Professor EDWIN CANNAN (Hon. Secretary).

Professor A. C. Pigou. Sir SYDNEY CHAPMAN, K.C.B., C.B.E.

Mr. L. L. PRICE (Hon. Secretary). Dr. J. H. CLAPHAM, C.B.E.

Professor W. R. Scott, Litt.D., Professor H. CLAY.

F.B.A. Miss C. E. COLLET.

Sir H. LLEWELLYN SMITH, G.C.B. Mr. 0. T. FALK, C.B.E.

Sir J. C. STAMP, K.B.E., Sc.D. Mr. A. W. Flux, C.B.

The Right Hon. SIDNEY WEBB.
Professor H, S. FOXWELL, F.B.A.

Mr. HARTLEY WITHERS.
(Hon. Secretary).
Mr. ALFRED HOARE, Hon Treasurer.
Prof. F. Y. EDGEWORTH, F.B.A.)

Joint Editors.
Mr. J. M. KEYNES, C.B.
Mr. J. M. KEYNES, C.B., Secretary.
Mr. S. J. BUTTRESS, Asst. Secretary.

Applications for Fellowship should be addressed by letter to the SECRETARY, Royal Economic Society, 9, Adelphi Terrace, London, W.C. 2. The Annual Subscription is a Guinea. Any Fellow may compound for his future yearly payments by a Life Subscription of Ten Guineas. There is at present no entrance fee. Libraries of a public or semi-public character are admitted to subscribing membership on special terms, which can be obtained on application to the Secretary.

Books and Periodicals for Review should be addressed to the Editor, Royal Economic Society, 9, Adelphi Terrace, London, W.C. 2.

Editorial Communications should be addressed to J. M. KEYNES, Esq., C.B., King's College, Cambridge.

All communications respecting Advertisements to be sent to
WALTER JUDD, Ltd., 97, Gresham Street, London, E.C. 2

VOLUME XXXIV
ARTICLES :-

Armstrong, W. E., Rossel Island Money : A Unique Monetary System
Ashley, Prof. Sir William, A Retrospect of Free-trade Doctrine ...
Bellerby, J. R., The Monetary Policy of the Future ... ... ...
Bickerdike, C. F., Individual and Social Interests in Relation to Saving
Bowley, Prof. A. L., Births and Population in Great Britain ... ...
Buckley, H., Sir Thomas Gresham and the Foreign Exchanges
Cannan, Prof. E., Limitation of Currency or Limitation of Credit ?
*Carver, Prof. T. N., The Incidence of Costs ...
Clay, Prof. H., The Post-War Wages Problem ... ... ...
Copland, Prof. D. B., The Economic Situation in Australia, 1918–23...
Copland, Prof. D. B., Some Problems of Taxation in Australia ...
Discussion on Monetary Reform at Annual Meeting Prof. Cannan,

Mr. R. G. Hawtrey, Sir Charles Addis, Mr. J. M. Keynes, Lord

Milner ... ..
Fay, Prof. C. R., The Sale of Corn in the 19th Century
Grant, Miss I. F., The Income from a Scotch Farm in the 18th Century
Guillebaud, C. W., The Economics of the Dawes Report
Heaton, H., An Experiment in the Teaching of Economics ...
Keynes, J. M., A Comment on Prof. Cannan's Article ... ... ...
Keynes, J. M., Alfred Marshall, 1842-1924 ... ...
Lindsay, A. D., Organisation of Labour in the Army during the War
Richardson, J. H., The Family Allowance System ...
Robertson, D. H., Those Empty Boxes ... ... ... ... ...
Rowe, J. W. F., Wages in the Cotton Industry, 1914–1920 ... ...
Tocker, A. H., The Monetary Standards of New Zealand and Australia
Venn, J. A., The Report of the Agricultural Tribunal ...
Wadia, Prof. P. A., True Basis of Protection for India

...

257

:

REVIEWS :

Andréadès, A., La Population Anglaise. By Prof. A. L. Bowley
Angas, L. L. B., Germany and her Debts. By T. E. Gregory ... ...
Bellerby, J. R., Control of Credit as a Remedy for Unemployment. By

R. G. Hawtrey ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 440
Belloc, H., Economics for Helen. By Helène Reynard
Berridge, W. A., Cycles of Unemployment in the United States. By Sir

W. Beveridge ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
Beveridge, Sir W. H., Insurance for All and Everything. By N. B.

Dearle ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 441
Blanc, E. T., Co-operative Movement in Russia. By Henry Vivian ...
Bowley, A. L., The Mathematical Groundwork of Economics. By Prof.

F. Y. Edgeworth ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 430
Broughton, G. M., Labour in Indian Industries. By Clara E. Collet... 457
Bücher, K., Beiträge zur Wirtschaftsgeschichte. By Prof. E. Schwied-
land ... ... ..

121
Business Cycles and Unemployment. By Sir W. Beveridge ...
Campbell, P. C., Chinese Coolie Emigration. By Francis E. Lawley ... 254
Cannan, E., Money : its Connexion with Rising and Falling Prices.

By T. E. Gregory ... ...
Cassel, G., The Theory of Social Economy. By H. Phillips ... ...
Chen, Ta, Chinese Migrations. By Francis E. Lawley

... 254
Clark, G. N., The Dutch Alliance and the War against French Trade,

1689–1697. By George Edmundson

99

2436

PAGE
Comish, N. H., The Standard of Living. By Helène Reynard

452
Dibblee, G. B., The Psychological Theory of Value. By D. H. Robertson 606
Fahlbeck, P. E., Die Klassen und die Gesellschaft. By Prof. E.

Schwiedland ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
Finer, H., Representative Government and a Parliament of Industry. By

Graham Wallas ...
Fisher, Mrs. H. A. L., The Economic Position of the Married Woman.

By Prof. F. Y. Edgeworth ... ... .. ... ... ... 446
Flux, A. W., Economic Principles (Second Edition). By J. Lemberger 437
French, C. E., The Shop Committee in the United States. By. H. W.

Macrosty ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 467
Gide, Charles, Fourier, précurseur de la Coopération. By L. Smith-
Gordon ... ... ...

... ... ... ... ... ... 614
Hainisch, M., Die Landflucht. By Prof. E. Schwiedland ... ... 468
Hardy, C. O., Risk and Risk-bearing. By D. H. Robertson ...

608
Hastings, H. B., Costs and Profits : their Relation to Business Cycles.
By C. F. Bickerdike ... ... ...

95
Hearnshaw, F. C. J. Democracy and Labour By L. L. Price ... 449
Herkner, H., Die Arbeiterfrage. By Prof. E. Schwiedland ...

122
18 Unemployment Inevitable ? By N. B. Dearle ...

602
Jones, Eliot, The Trust Problem in the United States. By H. W.

Macrosty ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
Joseph, H. W. B., The Labour Theory of Value in Karl Marx. By

James Bonar ... ... ... ... ... ... .. ...
Kennedy, W. P. M., Edited by, Social and Economic Conditions in

108
Keynes, J. M., Monetary Reform. By R. G. Hawtrey ... ... ... 227
Kötzschke, R., Allgemeine Wirthschaftsgeschichte des Mittelalters. By
J. H. Clapham ... ... ... ... ... ... ...

471
Kuske, B., Die Bedeutung Europas für die Entwicklung der Weltwirt-

schaft. By Prof. E. Schwiedland ... ... ... ... ... 474
Lavergne, B., Les coopératives de la consommation en France. By L.
Smith-Gordon ... ...

... ... ... ... 614
Lawrence, F. W. Pethick, The National Debt. By Prof. Edwin Cannan 609
Lescure, J., Des crises générales et périodiques de surproduction. By
J. I. Craig ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...

613
Levy, H., Die Vereinigten Staaten von Amerika als Wirtschaftsmachet.

By Prof. J. H. Hollander ... ... ... ... ... ... 473
Lord, J., Capital and Steam-power, 1750–1800. By T. S. Ashton ... 617
Lotz, W., Valutafrage und öffentliche Finanzen in Deutschland. By
T. E. Gregory ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...

101
Lowenfeld, H., The Birthright of Man. By J. Lemberger ...

621
Maclaren, W. A., Rubber, Tea and Cacao. By E. Cleveland Stevens... 624
Marriott, J. A. R., Economics and Ethics. By E. F. Jacobs ... ... 248
Menger, Carl, Grundsätze der Volkswirtschaftslehre. By J. Bonar .. 241
Miles, T. B., Industrial Unrest : its Cause and a Suggested Cure. By
J. Lemberger ... ... ... ... ... ... ...

621
Moreland, W. H., From Akbar to Aurangzeb. By Sir Theodore Morison 266
Munro, A. E., Monetary Theory before Adam Smith. By Prof. W. R.

Scott ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 264
Nippold, O., The Development of International Law after the World War.
By J. L. Brierly

125
Nussbaum, F. L., Commercial Policy in the French Revolution. By

Prof. Holland Rose ...
Ogata, K., The Co-operative Movement in Japan. By Prof. E.

Schwiedland ...
Pasvolsky, L., and Moulton, H. G., Russian Debts and Russian Recon-

struction. By L. Alston ... ... ... ... ... ...
Perlman, S., History of Trade Unionism in the United States. By

H. W. Macrosty ... ... ... ... ... ... ...